Modals and Tense
نویسنده
چکیده
Several recent works on modals and tense argue that epistemic modals and similar types of predicates are deprived of temporal properties. This article takes a different stand. Although epistemic modals typically express what may be dubbed “unchanging truths”, there exist examples to demonstrate that these types of predicates are still able to express a shift in temporal reference. This being the case, epistemic modals cannot be “outside the scope of tense altogether”, as claimed by Cinque (1999) and many others. This is as expected on the tense system I outline here, since I defend the idea that any verb is inherently temporal; specifically, that every verb contains a tense element, partaking in a temporal chain where only the topmost member is finite; the remaining members are non-finite. By means of this system, I investigate the temporal construal of root and epistemic modal constructions.
منابع مشابه
The grammatical category of modality∗
In many languages, the same words are used to express epistemic and root modality. These modals further tend to interact with tense and aspect in systematic ways, based on their interpretation. Is this pattern accidental, or a consequence of grammar or meaning? I address this question by: (i) comparing ‘grammatical’ modals to verbs/adjectives that share meanings with modals, but not the same sc...
متن کاملHana Filip and Greg
There are various opinions about how the phenomenon of sentential genericity (Carlson and Pelletier, 1995) is related to other classes of expressions of natural language. The notion of 'genericity' is most commonly viewed as having close ties to tense, mood and aspect (cf. Dahl, 1985; Comrie, 1985). For instance, philosophers and occasionally linguists (e.g. Dahl, 1975, 1985, and 1995) make use...
متن کاملAspects of Modality
It is a cross-linguistically robust fact that the same modal auxiliaries come in different flavors: epistemic, deontic, ability, teleological... This fact is neatly captured in a system where each modal has a single lexical entry, where the difference in flavor comes from contextuallyprovided accessibility relations (cf. Lewis 1973, Kratzer 1981). Equally robust, however, are the phenomena that...
متن کاملDynamic Discourse Referents for Tense and Modals
In each case, the anaphorically related elements are italicized. In (1a), \a presentation" is the antecedent for the pronoun \it", and in (1b), \gave a presentation" is the antecedent for the VPE. Similarly, in (1c), we view the \past" in the rst clause as the antecedent for the \past" in the second clause. This links the time of leaving to the time of giving the presentation. In (1d), we regar...
متن کاملThe Anaphoric Parallel between Modality and Tense
In modal subordination, a modal sentence is interpreted relative to a hypothetical scenario introduced in an earlier sentence. In this paper, I argue that this phenomenon reflects the fact that the interpretation of modals is an ANAPHORIC process, precisely analogous to the anaphoric interpretation of tense. Modal morphemes introduce alternative scenarios as entities into the discourse model; t...
متن کامل